HOME
LAKES
REPORTS
FORUMS
TRAVEL
DEALS
SEARCH
MORE
General Discussion

42" Lawn Riding Mower Recommendations

5/3/24 @ 7:13 AM
INITIAL POST
Timmothy A
User since 5/17/09

I am in the market for a new 42" traditional riding lawn mower.  I have a large lot with a lot of pine tress that I go around.  The current 42" deck gets me between 95% of them.  A tight turning radius is a key feature (duh right?).  Currently it takes me a solid hour to mow it.  I am thinking about getting something just a tad smaller deck due to the trees if that matters to your thought process. I also do quite of bit of towing a large cart full of landscaping materials. 

The budget is about $2500 max with the closer to $2000 or under the better.  I want something that will last me 20 years plus.  The Poulon I bought 10 years ago is ok but the hydrostatic tranny is not holding up.  Hit me with recommendations or ones to avoid.

Displaying 1 to 15 of 15 posts
5/8/24 @ 6:46 PM
Fishrun
Fishrun
User since 6/8/20
Replaced my JD 160 with a 38" deck after 35 years. Got a JD E140 with a 48" deck. The turning radius on the bigger deck is tighter than the old smaller deck. Hope to get 35 years out of this one.
5/8/24 @ 12:49 PM
Timmothy A
User since 5/17/09
I believe I am going the brews4995 route and getting a Deere from a Deere dealer.  They are $100 more at the dealer vs big box, but that $100 is priceless to have the ability to get it fixed/serviced by the place I bought it from in the town I work in.
5/5/24 @ 9:59 AM
dufferfish
User since 1/28/07
I have a john deere 42" deck hydro static home depot ​works great.D125 model
5/5/24 @ 9:54 AM
brews4995
brews4995
User since 4/2/10
Get a John Deere 100 series from an actual John Deere dealer, not box store like Lowe's. The 110 or 120 will be under $3000, will have a 3 year warranty and they are solid machines. Maintenance is a breeze also. 
5/5/24 @ 8:27 AM
Zmaniac
Zmaniac
PRO MEMBER User since 2/8/06
Arthur… There are mixed reviews on the battery powered Cubs. The people that have recently purchased one love it, but the people that have owned one for a few years aren’t happy. It seems that people that need them serviced are very disappointed in the support from the manufacturer. They are manufactured by MTD who makes quality gas mowers sold under different brands, but the electric line of large mowers have had reliability issues. 
5/5/24 @ 7:54 AM
arthur1957
arthur1957
User since 6/24/01
Has anyone here bought a Cub Cadet battery powered tractor? Know anyone that has one & what real world experience is? I thought about it for a few minutes. Then the local dealer went our of business. i would never buy from a big box store. I worked at Farm & Fleet for 7 months before i retired. I saw teen agers assembling all the lawn equipment in the warehouse.   Wouldn't trust anything they assembled. 
5/4/24 @ 9:37 PM
JACKWAGON 999
User since 8/12/20
42" Cub Cadet - 10 years old. pull wood trailer with a face cord of wood around the yard. Awesome macine. 
5/4/24 @ 11:41 AM
fltlndr
User since 12/25/02
Their all good as long as you maintain them..
5/4/24 @ 11:16 AM
arthur1957
arthur1957
User since 6/24/01

fltlndr
I had 40" Ariens with 14HP Briggs OHV, pressurized oil for 25 seasons. Just finished mowing with my 42" Snapper. 

42
5/4/24 @ 10:23 AM
Bassmaster+recordracks 2
Bassmaster+recordracks 2
PRO MEMBER User since 7/24/20
I haven’t had a riding lawnmower for years. But I would recommend getting a 48 inch. It’ll save a little bit of time just saying.
5/4/24 @ 10:17 AM
fltlndr
User since 12/25/02
I have a arians 20 hp with a 42ins deck and snowblower for the winter. it works very well summer and winter. It has the kohler engine with presureized oil and filter. Runs well and easy to maintain.
5/4/24 @ 9:09 AM
arthur1957
arthur1957
User since 6/24/01
I would seriously look for a low hour, used Simplicity or Snapper of recent manufacture. Briggs & Stratton abruptly ceased production in September & I drive from Beloit to Fon du Lac to procure one for $3k. At 67, should last my life as I got 26 season out of my old Aiens. I am not a fan of zero turns. I have used a Snapper & a Dixon at my church for 24 years and cannot not tear up the turf no matter how careful I am when turning around. 
5/3/24 @ 11:02 AM
Zmaniac
Zmaniac
PRO MEMBER User since 2/8/06
I have a Craftsman 46” tight turn lawn tractor that I’ve had for about 5 years. My big yard also has quite a few trees and I have no problems mowing around them and other tight areas. This particular mower is manufactured by MTD as is the similar models that carry the Cub Cadet and Husqvarna names. I’ve never had any issues with the mower and it seems to handle the steep incline of my yard and driveway. I also use it to pull a small trailer and spreader when needed.

https://www.craftsman.com/products/cm13apa9zsa93/42-in-20-hp-kohler%C2%AE-hydrostatic-turn-tight%E2%84%A2-gas-riding-lawn-mower-t2200k​​​
42
5/3/24 @ 10:26 AM
Prop
Prop
User since 4/9/03
Unless you want tractor for snow blowing, I would go with a zero turn. It would take 15-20 minutes off your mowing time. You can still pull a trailer with it.  
Displaying 1 to 15 of 15 posts
Copyright © 2001-2024 Lake-Link Inc. All rights reserved.
No portion of this website can be used or distributed without prior written consent of Lake-Link, Inc.
This website may contain affiliate links, meaning when you click the links and make a purchase, we may receive a small commission.
Lake-Link Home
ice drilled by
MENU
MORE TO EXPLORE